Blockcast
Blockcast delivers unfiltered analysis of crypto's most compelling narratives. Each week, seasoned industry insider Takatoshi Shibayama sits down with founders, CEOs, and key players shaping the blockchain landscape to dissect emerging projects, market dynamics, and institutional moves.
From trending protocols to strategic industry shifts, get an insider's take on the forces driving decentralized innovation and the decisions that matter. No fluff, no hype—just deep dives into what's really happening in crypto.
Blockcast
Animoca Brands Founder Yat Siu on the Metaverse's Relevancy in TradFi Crypto Adoption | Blockcast 39
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Becoming a yearly tradition, Blockhead caught up with Yat Siu once again in Bali at Coinfest 2024. Since our last catch-up with the Animoca Brands founder, the crypto industry has experienced floods of TradFi money flowing into the market, bolstered by the likes of Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs. But how does this renewed interest from old-school money fair for old-school Web3 projects like the metaverse and blockchain gaming?
Yat Siu shares his insights on how TradFi can complement these facets of Web3 and how Animoca Brands is adjusting to new market demands as well as fulfilling its long-term needs. Additionally, we learn about why Saudi Arabia deserves the crypto industry's attention and how regional developments are shaping the landscape.
More at Blockhead.co and join us on Telegram to stay up to date with the latest news.
🎙️ Hey there, Blockcast listeners! 🎙️ This podcast provides commentary and discussion on cryptocurrency and related topics. It is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be construed as financial advice. Guests appearing on this podcast may discuss companies or strategies, but these discussions are not recommendations to buy, sell, or hold any particular asset or pursue any specific strategy. The hosts and guests are not financial advisors, and listeners are urged to consult with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions. Investments in cryptocurrency are inherently risky, and you could lose money.
Reach us at hello@blockhead.co.
Hey there, Crypto Curious gang. It's time to plug in and play with the Blockheads at BlockCast. Strap in for a weekly whirlwind tour through the blockchain jungle, where NFTs, shiny coins, and crypto titans tango. Serve that with a side of spicy insights and the crunchiest bits of the digital sphere. Let's dive into the decentralized deep end. BlockCast is live in 3, 2, 1.
SPEAKER_02Hi everyone, welcome to BlockCast. I'm your host for today, Kohan, co-founder of Blockhead. For a second year in a row at CoinFest, we caught up with a very prominent name in Web3, especially in the gaming and metaverse space. Co-founder and chairman of Animoca Brands, Yat Su has played a significant role in the development of blockchain gaming, NFTs, and DeFi. How are you doing, Yat? Very good.
SPEAKER_01Great to see you guys again.
SPEAKER_02Cool. We spoke to you last time at CoinFest. And since then, the crypto industry has obviously gone through quite the transformation with a swathe of institutional adoption. Sure. But what has changed the biggest for you and Animoca?
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, I think the biggest thing that's changed for us over the last 12 months is that as an industry, you know, we're very much focused on trying to bring in more institutional flows, right? We can see that already happening, not just with the ETFs, but Animoca is also looking at a stablecoin project with Standard Chartered, for instance. The work that we're doing in Saudi with Neom is also part of bringing more, I guess, institutions into the Web3 space. But of course, the other thing that hasn't really changed is our focus on culture and entertainment. We're very much trying to continue to drive Web3 gaming as a narrative. We invested in Ton last year, and that's something that we're really trying to push as a narrative to help bring more mass adoption. So projects like Gaming for instance have now reached 90 million users thanks to basically sort of the Tom Telegram type of integration that we've seen there so again that's something we encourage companies to do so those have been some of the things and of course the launch of the Mochaverse and the Mocha token is also something that we just did last month in a difficult market but actually had some pretty good success so far as a way to help expand the network effects of Animoca.
SPEAKER_02Have there been any partnerships or investments that are further aligned towards institutional investors and you know with the whole praise obviously institutions getting into the space?
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, I think Animoca itself is a company that is very much focused around due to its cap table. We already have a lot of institutions in this and as shareholders. And so we continue to look at expanding that. We've had some interested high level partnerships happening in the space. If you look at Mochaverse, for instance, when we did that effectively sort of equity slash token raise for the project, you know, we had CMCC, we've had various other parties sort of invest in it, Kingsway Capital, Liberty City Ventures, and those are kind of institutional groups in that. But But, you know, again, I would say that the growth of the Web3 space so far is not seeing massive growth on the consumer side, right? I think people are sort of a little bit on the sidelines. I think that's going to happen as well. Frankly, I think the end of the year, the way the election will go may have an impact in that as well. Most of our growth that we're seeing is coming from Asia and the Middle East for the time being, which makes sense because they've been very open towards Web3 and crypto broadly.
SPEAKER_02As blockchain technology becomes more widely adopted, what are the biggest challenges that companies like Anamoka face in scaling?
SPEAKER_01So the biggest challenge that generally the industry faces, which we face as well, is how do we get people who are not in Web3 or who are not financially literate to understand the value of Web3, right? We were trying to push digital property rights. What's the basis of digital property rights? Well, you know, if you have property rights, you know, you have to understand a little bit about capitalism. You have to understand about money. You have to understand about sort of the nature of investing and financial literacy has to go up. That's the hope and that's the promise. The challenge is that most people are not financially literate. So in a festival like you at Coinbase, everyone generally has an investing mindset, right? But when you talk to a lot of your friends, probably, they don't think of it that way, right? Which is one of the reasons why the world is, I think, as troubled as it is because the class of people that understand money, the capital class, as we'd call it, are doing reasonably well. And the one that's very focused on the labor economy and doesn't understand money that well haven't done well over the last 20 years. And so that's why we have a lot of rift in the world, you know, questions on equity and, of course, the politics around it. And I think that's a challenge, really. We have to, you know, using storytelling and gaming, for instance, and education as a way, which is what we're trying to do with Open Campus, to help drive, essentially, people's understanding why Web3 is so important for you. It's interesting you mentioned the different classes,
SPEAKER_02because the next question is more in line of someone like Coinfest, which is one extreme of us all networking in shorts, slides and everything. It's quite a contrast to Wall Street suits, right? So how do brands like Animoca encompass the Web3 spirit so heavily? How do you maintain the spirit and, like, the decentralized ethos in the face of increasing institutional influence?
SPEAKER_01Okay, so first, I don't believe that a space can grow without institutional influence. The reason why is that most of the capital in the world does depend on institutions as a base, I would say. If you take a look at the mass adoption, we're talking about mass adoption. Well, how do we bring mass adoption to Web3 if we don't bring the institution? So to me, it's not about being against the institution. It's more about how do we integrate them into the system and then make it broadly more echo as a framework, right? And I would argue that's already beginning. If you look at the stock market today, 80% of the equity markets is purely institutional. When you look at tokens or you look at Web3 space, that's not nearly that much. I think your institutional flow into Bitcoin, maybe 10, 14%, something like that, right? So you have a complete inverse of that. In an ideal scenario, maybe you get 50-50, right? And that to me would seem like a good balance, right? You don't want necessarily one to have too much than the other. And I think that's the mission. And right now, you know, when you look at what's happening with Bitcoin ETF and Ethereum ETF coming already in Hong Kong and in the US and other places soon. I expect fully that different type of tokens will end up also becoming ETFs as a way to bring in institutional flows. That to me is just step one into eventually having them join a decentralized ecosystem, right? I mean, once you have Bitcoin or once you have Ethereum, the next thing you say, okay, I have it in a fund. Now maybe I want to take it out and do something with it. That to me seems a natural transition. We got to begin that journey somewhere. But do you think Wall Street has a genuine interest and
SPEAKER_02belief in a technology in Web3?
SPEAKER_01I would say there is a belief among some. I think there is a skepticism maybe still on most. And then I think there's another one which is more sanguine about it, which is they're more likely to know it's a way to make money. Sure, right? But I think broadly speaking, when you think about people who reach a certain type of capital, what they're concerned about is safety and security, right? And what do they want to protect against? They want to protect against their forms of freedom, right? Which means that How do I ensure that I have the type of security and the freedom? Well, that means I want to have my assets away from some kind of central control. And I think that's one of the narratives that really spoke extremely well to some of the big, so let's call it institutions that have gotten into it, because they understand the importance of that, especially in light of recent history. So I think there is a strong narrative there around people who are at Wall Street, but who also want to essentially have the security of the true knowledge of having security on their assets. So yeah,
SPEAKER_02an interesting response. Beyond Bitcoin and Ethereum, do you think there's a growing interest in Wall Street in terms of other Web3 projects? I mean, such as the Metaverse and DeFi, NFTs, etc. Do you think there's opportunities there?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. When we talk to various fund managers, there's a great interest in taking a look at multiple type of sort of tokens out there. And I think the main reason they look at that is because they look at it as a way to find, sort of participate in Web3. It's not that they have the ability to gain attention to every token that's out there, but they do want to participate in that because they see its importance. So for instance, maybe a few years ago, Solana would have never had sort of that conversation. And now Solana is there. And TON, which is a fairly new one, one that we are, you know, big supporters of. The TON ecosystem is something that has a lot of institutional support that actually, you know, again, maybe a year ago was maybe broadly unknown. And today is in everyone's lips, for instance, where big funds, including the likes of Pantera and Kingsway and so on, have all started taking a stake in Inquisition. So you can see that happening already.
SPEAKER_02The media, including us, I guess, has been very preoccupied with everything that's going on in the ETF world, et cetera, et cetera. But we're curious to know what's going on with blockchain gaming. How is that industry developing and what are the challenges facing the industry in the current climate?
SPEAKER_01So first, I think blockchain gaming is actually due quite well. I know that there's a lot of people who are like, oh, look at token prices, whatever. But I think one thing that people sometimes forget is that three years ago, there was a concentration of only a few blockchain games. So think of it as a little bit as the market was concentrated in just a few. So when you look at the NFT market, you know, people say, oh, look at Bored Apes. Well, it's still a 13E, which, by the way, is not a small sum of money for an NFT. Let's just be clear. But more important, and remember, when Bored Apes was sold in the beginning, it was really just a couple hundred bucks. But Bored Apes represented 90% of the NFT market in 21, 22, right? And now you have many more NFTs that are actually significant. Whether you look at Pudgies, whether you look at Mad Labs, whether you look at Mookiverse, whether you look at, of course, Port Apes and so on, and then the various gaming projects. So it's a much broader market. And then you look at Bitcoin, Ordinals as well, right? Again, that's expanded the NFT space. So it's not that it's a smaller market. It's just a more diversified space. And I think the same is true when you think about gaming projects, right? You know, before all the attention was on Axie Infinity. Axie Infinity is still doing okay, but Then you have Pixels, and you've got basically sort of, you know, chains like SAI, right? And you've got, of course, projects like Rev, and you've got, you know, Gamey. All of these projects are basically there adding to the gaming narrative, and it's growing. If you look at the number of users that are on things like Hamster Combat, Gamey has 90 million users right now, you know, three to four million sort of daily active users because of TonTelegram in its gaming platform. Those are numbers that even Web2 gaming companies would say, wow, that's pretty good, right? So we're getting there. But, you know, and in some ways, because the hype has died down a little bit from what happened a few years ago, this sort of building and within the communities is excitement. Outside, people haven't seen the narrative, but I believe that people will pay attention to it again when they see those numbers grow and increase. Because at the end of the day, users matter, right? And you'll see that growth is happening. And you can clearly see it when you look at what's happening on
SPEAKER_02Ton. Speaking of hype, we've seen a lot of celebrities promoting NFTs, especially this year and other WebView projects. Do you think this is a positive? or does it create an unrealistic expectation and potentially even mislead investors?
SPEAKER_01So I don't think that there's too many celebrities pushing NFTs right now. I think they're pushing more meme coins.
SPEAKER_02Pushing projects, I guess.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I would say, so one, I think there are some celebrities going out there that are, you know, pushing sort of tokens, meme coins in particular, and you see various versions. I mean, you know, you've got like, you know, one of the Jenners, you know, basically doing it as well. So you've got like crazy stuff like that happening. Honestly, we don't really partake in these things in the sense that, you know, it's not part of our thesis, but we do think they play an important role. I think meme coins are a response to the market and the culture we're in right now, right? I think of meme coins somewhat, you know, and of course there's people who do take advantage of it, but a little bit of a response to, you know, the fuck you mentality to Wall Street, kind of like Wall Street bets type of thing and sort of what happened with GameStop. A little bit of that reaction, some fun as well, you know, quite a bit of speculating, right? But how I look at NFTs, for instance, which I think not that many celebrities are pushing them per se, the native projects, I actually think those are going to be much more foundational. And the reason why is because, you know, what is it that's most important for us as people in the sort of mid to long run, especially when you've reached a certain kind of wealth? It's your cultural, it's your social, and it's your symbolic capital. And that's not represented based on how many tokens you have, it's represented by what type of asset you have. You see this in the real world. Why does someone want a Picasso? Why do they want a Lamborghini? Why do they want a Ferrari? Why do they want to live in a nice villa, for instance, right? In an expensive place when they could move somewhere else where you could make a bigger house, right? It's not the utility, it's the status symbol implied. And so that's one of the reasons why, you know, Bored Apes went through a rough patch last year. But now, again, number one Ethereum NFT project at 13E for instance, you know, these are projects that people want to hold because having one, it confers you status within that community, right? So I think that's, to me, that's why I think NFTs are currently undervalued. And again, I would say the time to invest in the market is when people are not paying attention, right? So in other words, if you invest in the hot narratives of today, you're probably coming in at more of a peak of a market, especially if you're not knowledgeable in that, right? I mean, we got into gaming in 2018, 2019, right? And nobody cared about that, right? In some ways, I think that's the opportunity as well here now. So I think Web3 gaming is going to be, you know, even bigger in the coming years. Cool.
SPEAKER_02Hey, changing topics slightly. Last year, I don't know if you remember, after we finished the interview, you said to us, keep your eye on Saudi Arabia. Just watch it. Yes. Now, one year since Has the region fulfilled your prediction? What aspects were you...
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, certainly for Animoca, it's been great. I mean, we've opened a strategic partnership with Neom. They became investors in us. They opened up a Web3 hub. They're the largest gaming investors in the world, for instance, which is relevant to us as well. They're building in sports and entertainment and culture. I mean, you think about Saudi as a nation, you know, independent of just related to Web3 stuff, you know, Saudi is one of the few countries in the world that are actually pushing growth narratives, right? I mean, many other places in the world are thinking more about how to sort of shrinking and reduction and sort of, you know, right-sizing, right? Saudi is like just grow, grow, grow, grow, right? And then the region as a whole, you know, when you look at UAE, for instance, or I was just in Istanbul, I mean, Turkey as well, especially when it comes to Web3, is a pretty exciting market too. So I think Saudi, I think is going to be a market that will spearhead that in large part because there's a young demographic. And by the way, that's, I think, also the reasons why I think Indonesia has a lot of potential because it's the same thing, right? It's a young demographic. It's a native demographic towards people who are familiar with technology as a whole. Web3 is more native to them. And also, I think, you know, Web3 and blockchain is something that will solve many problems for them. You know, financial inclusion, financial access, you know, transfer of funds, very basic utility stuff as a starting point.
SPEAKER_02Do you think Saudi Arabia has embraced Web3 as a genuine attempt to diversify its economy?
SPEAKER_01So it's early days, right? So the reality, of course, is that, you know, Saudi is not UAE for the time being, but they've made commitments, right? I mean, they're building a Web3 hub with us, right? They've made investments in companies like us to grow the space. And I can't say who, but there's a number of members in the royal family who have some NFTs. And so the point is that it's already beginning.
SPEAKER_02Is there any specific policy or something that Saudi Arabia is working towards or issues that you think is particularly exciting?
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, I think working on the KSA, we're opening up the Web3 hub, which is basically with a government group. And of course, receiving funding from NEOM, which is part of PIF, which is a Saudi sovereign fund, I think is a pretty good indicator that they're trying to push this forward.
SPEAKER_02Just talking about regions, Hong Kong is our hometown, and a lot of development of the S&S we last spoke. They've taken quite a liberal approach and, you know, they've taken on ETFs and everything, but not everything has played out, I guess, as well as they wanted it to go. What are your views on Hong Kong currently in this kind of Web3 landscape?
SPEAKER_01First, I mean, I think if you want to build a Web3 business, Hong Kong is one of the best places to do it. If you consider in terms of certain kind of clarity, openness, and of course, willingness to cooperate with, that to me is a big narrative. And I actually think that Hong Kong is, you know, wants to lead in Web3. You know, there's many macro themes around that. You know, de-dollarization is one. The second narrative, of course, is around how do we include more young people into the space, right? How do we make them more excited about the future? Again, that's Web3, right? And then also, you know, the future finance. I mean, I think at this point, it's pretty much established that blockchain and Web3 are going to be a very, very critical part of the future finance. And what is Hong Kong? It's a finance hub. If you want to stay relevant, then you've got to embrace it. And I think they understand that very, very well. Hong Kong Hong Kong has also, as you know, gone through a rough patch because of COVID and so on. And so they've lost their market share as a financial hub, which means that Hong Kong has become hungry for market share. So they have like a Web3 marketing fund. They've got investment funds from the government as well to help promote the space. You know, incubation, acceleration, all of that's happening there. So yeah, I couldn't be more excited about where Hong Kong is going.
SPEAKER_02Cool. And then finally, globally, how do you think economic downturns will affect the crypto industry and Animoca brands in particular?
SPEAKER_01The economic downturn, frankly, from a micro sense, we've experienced that over the last year and a half or more, you know, because of everything that happened in the industry, right? So I would say things are much, much better in comparison to a year ago, right? It's all taken from that lens of perspective. One of the things that's also interesting to observe is that, you know, really Web3 and crypto was supposed to be a kind of counter cyclical sort of argument towards, well, if the markets do badly, actually, there's another narrative around that that could give you sort of a hedge. And it's proven not to be quite the case. And I think that's a demonstration of the kind of institutional flows that have gotten into crypto as a whole, that if someone is looking at his stock portfolio and is not doing well, then he might have to liquidate his token portfolio, maybe to deal with something and vice versa. So it's becoming more interconnected, which is a double-edged sword, of course, but I think broadly a good thing. So I can think there's more of a connection there that's taken place, which I see as a positive development. But at the end of the day, blockchain, crypto, tokens are a I think, to the global economy. And also, at the end of the day, it's a new asset class. And this asset class is the network asset, right? It's an asset that has a network effect, which really equity doesn't have, gold doesn't have, maybe a little bit, right? But the network effects that we can have on owning essentially a token in the Web3 space is a unique proposition. And that's why I think people ultimately sort of want access to that because of a way of participation in this. Awesome.
SPEAKER_02Thanks
SPEAKER_01for
SPEAKER_02your time
SPEAKER_01and
SPEAKER_02your insights. We
SPEAKER_01appreciate
SPEAKER_02it. Thank you. Thanks for listening, everyone, and we'll see you in the next episode.